Quick picks: what are you doing?
- You want the closest thing to Vettted's $500 package, 10 mentions at a fixed price: Mention.Broker, $34.99 a month for 10 at its launch pricing.
- You want to pay per comment and get most of it back if moderators remove it: ReplyAgent, $4 a comment with a 70% refund on removal.
- You buy from an SEO agency already and want a white-label report: FATJOE, about $600 a campaign for 10 Reddit engagements.
- You want comments posted for you every day on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X at one flat price: CommunityMentions, $1,000 a month.
- You are a B2B SaaS company and want a replacement guarantee: SaaSy Links, from $650 a month.
- You can wait for Vettted: check its Reddit mentions page for the packages to come back.
Vettted alternatives compared
Each row gives the same fields from that vendor's own page, read November 7, 2026. CommunityMentions is ours.
| Service | What you buy | Price as published | Removal guarantee or refund | Best for | Where it still beats us |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vettted | Packages of human-written Reddit mentions from aged accounts | $500 (10 mentions, no links), $800 (10 with links), $1,500 (5 threads and 10 comments); all Paused | Every mention guaranteed for 3 months | Brands that want a fixed order with a thread list to approve | You approve the thread list before anything is placed |
| CommunityMentions (ours) | Daily comments posted for you on five channels | $1,000/mo after a $1 setup charge | The $1 setup charge back if nothing is delivered in the first week | Brands that want daily placements without managing an order | This is us |
| Mention.Broker | Monthly plans of Reddit mentions from real human accounts | $34.99/mo for 10, $89.99 for 30, $159.99 for 50 (launch pricing, struck-through list prices $49.99, $149.99, $249.99) | A satisfaction guarantee, as its page puts it | The lowest price per mention | Price: a few dollars a mention |
| ReplyAgent | Pay per comment or post; you find the threads, or pay for AI discovery | $4 a comment, $8 a post; AI features $79/mo | 70% back if moderators remove it, checked at 24 or 48 hours | Teams that pick their own threads | Pay only for what posts, no monthly fee |
| FATJOE | One campaign of 10 community engagements from a branded Reddit account | About $600 a campaign for 10 Reddit engagements (priced in pounds) | Removed posts replaced for up to 6 months if the total drops below the package | Agencies that resell under their own report | White-label report; a branded Reddit account created for you |
| Bazzly | Self-serve credits for warmed-account comments | $199/mo for 170 credits; a comment with 5 upvotes is 11 credits | 10 credits back if a warmed-account comment is removed within 48 hours | Teams that want to run it themselves on autopilot | 7-day free trial |
| SaaSy Links | Organic Reddit posting and commenting on established accounts | $650, $1,300 or $2,000/mo | 6-month replacement guarantee | B2B SaaS on a fixed budget | Posts as well as comments, with a replacement guarantee |
What Vettted's Reddit packages included
Vettted is a link-building and SEO agency; Reddit mentions are one of its services. Its page listed three packages on November 7, 2026, each marked Paused with no date for a return. The workflow it describes: you send your brand, URL, competitors and keywords, it shortlists threads (including ones that rank on Google) for you to approve, its team writes the comments. You get a spreadsheet with a link to every live mention.
| Package | What it listed | Price | Delivery | Status on Nov 7, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Standard (its most popular) | 10 Reddit mentions, no links | $500 | 14 days | Paused |
| Advanced | 10 Reddit mentions with links | $800 | 14 days | Paused |
| Premium | 5 Reddit threads and 10 comments | $1,500 | 30 days | Paused |
What 10 Reddit mentions cost elsewhere
Ten mentions cost from $34.99 to about $600 among the services still selling on November 7, 2026, against Vettted's $500 to $800. The gap is mostly who writes, whose account posts and whether anyone picks threads that rank. CommunityMentions doesn't sell by count.
| Service | 10 mentions | What changes the price |
|---|---|---|
| Vettted (paused) | $500 without links, $800 with | Human-written, aged accounts, threads you approve |
| Mention.Broker | $34.99 a month (Starter, launch pricing) | Real human accounts; 1 campaign and 3 keywords on Starter |
| ReplyAgent | $40 at $4 each | You find the threads unless you pay $79/mo for AI discovery |
| FATJOE | About $600 | One campaign with a white-label report |
| Bazzly | About $199 buys 15 comments with upvotes (170 credits at 11 each) | You run it yourself |
| CommunityMentions (ours) | Not sold by count | $1,000 a month for daily comments on five channels |
Links or no links: what our data shows
Vettted charged $300 more for the same 10 mentions with links. Links are rare on Reddit. Of 115,532 comments we scanned across 187 subreddits (comments scanned up to October 30, 2026), 2.5% contained a link. The median subreddit was at 1.5%, and in 71 of the 187 fewer than 1 in 100 comments carried one. A mention without a link looks like the rest of the thread, and Vettted's own FAQ says a linkless mention feels more natural on Reddit and is more likely to stay live.
| Subreddit | Comments scanned | Share with a link |
|---|---|---|
| r/smallbusiness | 237 | 0.4% |
| r/SaaS | 298 | 0.7% |
| r/Entrepreneur | 2,114 | 2.0% |
| r/marketing | 1,582 | 2.0% |
| r/startups | 884 | 3.2% |
| r/b2bmarketing | 421 | 11.6% |
Where Vettted still wins, once it reopens
- You approve the exact threads before anything is placed. We have you approve the voice in Slack, not each thread.
- People write every comment, per its page. Ours are AI-written in a voice you approve.
- A fixed order with a fixed price, and a 3-month guarantee on each mention.
- Link building and SEO packages from the same agency. We sell neither.
Which one fits
If you wanted Vettted for a one-off order of 10 mentions, Mention.Broker and ReplyAgent are the nearest on price, and FATJOE is the nearest on a managed one-off campaign. If you wanted mentions every week without placing orders, CommunityMentions posts daily for $1,000 a month, and you can read a free sample first.
How we compared
Vettted's packages come from its Reddit mentions page, read November 7, 2026. Every other vendor's price comes from its own pricing page, read the same day. The link shares come from CommunityMentions' subreddit dataset, which also powers our subreddit pages. We have not bought Vettted's packages. If a vendor's page says something different now, its page wins.
Sources
- Vettted Reddit mentions, read November 7, 2026: three packages, all marked Paused; 3-month guarantee; spreadsheet report.
- Mention.Broker, ReplyAgent pricing, FATJOE community mentions, Bazzly pricing and SaaSy Links, read November 7, 2026.
- CommunityMentions subreddit dataset: 115,532 comments scanned across 187 subreddits, comments scanned up to October 30, 2026, read November 7, 2026.
- Our price and terms: pricing section and company facts, read November 7, 2026.