Who wrote this and how we checked
CommunityMentions wrote this page, and we sell a competing service, so read it as a vendor's comparison. Every ReplyAgent fact below comes from replyagent.ai home and pricing pages, read on October 6, 2026. If their page says something different now, their page wins.
Our numbers come from our delivery records. In the 30 days of comments posted from August 30 to September 28, 2026, the median client (41 clients) had 106 placements still live at the last check, across Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X. 11 of them were on Reddit. Comments that were removed after we first verified them are not counted.
Strandline Research's comparison of 11 done-for-you Reddit marketing services (same owner as us) scores each on 7 published criteria.
ReplyAgent vs CommunityMentions at a glance
| ReplyAgent (checked Oct 6, 2026) | CommunityMentions | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $79/mo AI plan; posting from its accounts $4 a comment, $8 a post | $1,290/mo after a $1 setup charge |
| What the price buys | 30 comments: about $120 plus the plan | A median of 106 live placements a month, 11 on Reddit |
| Who posts | Its pool of aged Reddit accounts, or your own | People with established accounts post comments AI drafts in the voice you approve in Slack |
| Removed comments | 70% refund if moderators remove a comment by its 24-hour check | No credit; every removal shows in your daily report |
| Upvotes | Not stated | Not sold |
| Channels | Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X | |
| Reporting | Visibility checks at 1 and 24 hours, comment tracking, UTM analytics | Daily Slack report with a link to each live comment |
| Minimum term | None, cancel anytime | None, month-to-month |
| How you start | 3-day free trial | Free sample of the comments we'd post, no card |
Where ReplyAgent wins
- Price per comment. Posting from its accounts is $4 a comment.
- Partial refunds. 70% back if moderators remove the comment by its 24-hour check.
- Flexibility. Post from its accounts or your own, pay as you go.
Where CommunityMentions fits better
- You want more than Reddit. ReplyAgent is Reddit only; we cover five channels.
- You want it fully done for you, with no tool to run. We find the threads, draft and post every comment, and report each one.
- You want a check that runs past day one. We re-check each comment nightly for about a week and report the removals.
Which one fits
If you want the most Reddit comments per dollar, ReplyAgent costs less per comment than we do. Our Reddit volume is lower: the median client had 11 live Reddit comments in the month above. If you want placements across five channels, done for you and reported comment by comment, that's what the $1,290 covers. Start with the free sample and compare the comments themselves.