CommunityMentions
Glossary
Updated November 19, 2026By Ryan Doyle, founder of CommunityMentions

What Is Astroturfing on Reddit?

Astroturfing means hiding who sponsors a message so it looks like spontaneous grassroots support. On Reddit it is paid or coordinated posting that passes as ordinary users' opinions. A brand should care because the FTC treats undisclosed paid endorsements and fake reviews as enforcement targets.

Run my free sample

1985

year Lloyd Bentsen is credited with coining the term, per Wikipedia (read Nov 19, 2026)

8,792

subreddits where we have verified Reddit comments (Nov 10, 2025 to Sep 26, 2026)

120+

client brands with a verified placement from us, as of Sep 27, 2026

At a glance

QuestionAnswer
What it isHiding who pays for or organizes a message so it looks like unprompted opinion.
Who sees itReaders, moderators, Reddit's admins and, for paid endorsements, the FTC.
Why it matters to a brandPaid comments that read as organic can breach platform rules and advertising law, and readers punish them when found.
What to doApply the three-question test below to every comment before it posts, whoever writes it.

An example from our data

We run a paid comment service, so this line matters to our own work. As of September 26, 2026, we had verified Reddit comments in 8,792 subreddits, and as of September 27, 2026 we had 120+ client brands with at least one verified placement. This is not a hypothetical for us. Moderators remove some comments over time, usually by hand. Each comment gets a same-afternoon check and a nightly re-check for about a week. A removal is not proof of astroturfing, since moderators act for many reasons, but it shows that communities police promotional content. We do not tag removals by reason, so we cannot say which ones looked paid.

How it works

Wikipedia defines astroturfing as hiding the sponsors of an orchestrated message so it looks like unsolicited grassroots support. It credits Lloyd Bentsen with the term in 1985, after a flood of postcards and letters that insurance interests had generated. Its examples include the 2006 "Wal-Marting Across America" blog funded by Wal-Mart. Another is a 2010 FTC settlement with Reverb Communications, which had used interns to post favorable app reviews (Wikipedia, read November 19, 2026). The FTC's Endorsement Guides Q and A says to disclose a material connection when a significant minority of consumers would not expect it. Payment or anything of value usually requires disclosure. Endorsers cannot claim to have used a product they have not tried. Fake likes from nonexistent people are called clearly deceptive (FTC, read November 19, 2026). The FTC's final rule on fake reviews, announced in August 2024, bans reviews that misrepresent they are by someone who does not exist, and undisclosed insider reviews. It also bars buying fake social media indicators, such as bot-generated followers or views. That applies when the buyer knew or should have known they were fake (FTC press release, read November 19, 2026). Reddit's Rule 5 says: "Be authentic. You don't have to use your real name, but do not intentionally mislead others or impersonate an individual or entity in a deceptive manner" (Reddit Rules, read November 19, 2026). Rule 2 bars disruptive behaviors, including content manipulation. Neither rule uses the word astroturfing. Read the vote manipulation and spam sections of Reddit's help pages before you buy any service. Our upvotes entry covers voting, and the shadowban entry covers what happens to flagged accounts.

What CommunityMentions does

Our service sits close to this line, and we will not tell you which side it falls on. The facts are these. The comments are written by AI, tuned on what sticks and what AI answers cite. The client approves the voice and filters in Slack before anything goes live. Real people with established accounts post them, are paid per comment that sticks, and the accounts rotate. Each Reddit comment gets two checks: one the afternoon it is posted, then nightly for about a week. A daily Slack report links every comment that passed and counts those removed. Whether that is acceptable for your brand depends on what each comment says. It also depends on whether a reader would weigh it differently if they knew a brand paid for it. Use the test in the next section on our comments too. The real accounts versus bots comparison explains how our posters differ from automation.

How to check it

  • Test 1, experience: does the poster claim to have used the product or lived the situation? The FTC says endorsers cannot claim use they do not have.
  • Test 2, connection: would a reader weigh the comment differently if they knew a brand paid for it? If yes, the FTC says to disclose it near the comment, not in a separate place.
  • Test 3, accuracy: is every claim in the comment one you could defend to the subreddit's moderators and to a regulator?
  • If a comment fails any test, rewrite it or drop it. Approval in Slack is where you apply this, so read the drafts.
  • Prefer comments that answer the question and name the brand only when it fits. A reply that would help with no brand name in it passes more easily.

Common mistakes brands make

  • Believing that disclosure on a profile page is enough. The FTC wants it close to the endorsement.
  • Buying votes or accounts to make comments look popular. The FTC rule targets fake indicators of influence, and Reddit has its own vote rules.
  • Having employees post as ordinary users. The FTC page says employees should disclose their relationship when a post could promote the company.
  • Using the same sentence across subreddits. It looks coordinated even when the opinions are real.
  • Assuming a service's word that it is compliant. Read the comments and apply the test yourself.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What is astroturfing?

Hiding the sponsors of an organized message so it looks like unprompted grassroots support. The name comes from the artificial grass brand, and Wikipedia credits Lloyd Bentsen with it in 1985.

Is astroturfing illegal?

It depends on what is done. The FTC says undisclosed material connections can mislead, and its 2024 rule bans fake reviews and bought fake social indicators. This page is not legal advice.

Is paying for Reddit comments astroturfing?

It depends on whether the comments hide a connection readers would care about or claim experience the poster lacks. Apply the three-question test to each comment instead of judging a service by its label.

What does Reddit say about astroturfing?

Reddit's Rule 5 says to be authentic and not to intentionally mislead others or impersonate an individual or entity in a deceptive manner (Reddit Rules, read November 19, 2026). The rules do not use the word astroturfing, so read each subreddit's own rules too.

See the comments we would post for your brand

Paste your site and get a free sample of real comments for the threads your buyers read. No card needed. Nothing posts until you approve it in Slack.