CommunityMentions
Comparison
Updated November 19, 2026By Ryan Doyle, founder of CommunityMentions

ReplyAgent alternatives for founders and SaaS teams who want Reddit mentions: which of 10 options fits, with prices read November 16, 2026

Updated November 19, 2026. ReplyAgent is $4 a comment from its own accounts, or $79 a month for AI thread discovery and drafts (its pricing page, read November 16, 2026). For founders and SaaS teams who want Reddit mentions without picking every thread, CommunityMentions, ours, is $1,000 a month after a $1 setup charge, on five channels. Tools start at $19 a month.

Run my free sample

9 of 96

AI answers to Reddit marketing questions named ReplyAgent; CommunityMentions was named in 17 (our scan, Nov 2, 2026)

$4

a comment ReplyAgent posts from its own accounts; $8 a post; AI features $79 a month (read Nov 16, 2026)

$120

30 ReplyAgent comments a month at $4, its own typical-usage figure, before the $79 AI plan

$1,000

CommunityMentions a month, month to month, after a $1 setup charge

What are the best ReplyAgent alternatives?

The best ReplyAgent alternative depends on who you want doing the work. To keep paying per comment on a different network, choose Mention.Broker ($34.99 a month for 10 mentions) or CrowdReply, which sells placements from a credit marketplace on plans from $79 a month with no per-comment price (read November 19, 2026). For an AI tool that drafts replies and posts the ones you approve, ReplyGuy from $49 a month. To find threads and write the comments yourself, Redreach from $19, KWatch from $19 or RedShip from $29. For an agency at a published price, ReddiReach ($2,000) or OutreachBloom ($2,400 a month). For daily comments posted for you on five channels with no contract, CommunityMentions, ours, at $1,000 a month.

Quick picks: what are you doing?

  • You pick the threads and want low-cost posting per comment: stay with ReplyAgent at $4 a comment, $120 for 30 a month.
  • You want a different kind of network: CrowdReply, Starter $79 a month and Growth $239, with offsite mentions bought from a marketplace with credits, priced per placement and shown before you confirm (read November 19, 2026).
  • A fixed monthly plan where a pool of users posts mentions: Mention.Broker, $34.99 a month for 10 mentions, a launch price against $49.99 list.
  • A tool that finds buyers asking for your kind of product, drafts the reply and posts the ones you approve: ReplyGuy from $49 a month. See CommunityMentions vs ReplyGuy.
  • You find the threads and write and post yourself: Redreach from $19 a month, KWatch from $19, RedShip from $29 or Subreddit Signals from $29.
  • Comments written for you every day but posted from your own branded account: OutreachBloom, $2,400 a month, month to month.
  • An agency that posts and comments from a branded profile it manages: ReddiReach, $2,000 a month for 30 contributions, 3-month minimum.
  • Comments placed every day on Reddit and four other channels without a contract: CommunityMentions, ours, $1,000 a month after a $1 setup charge, starting with a free sample.

ReplyAgent alternatives compared

Ten alternatives run from $19 to $2,000 a month, and the first row is ReplyAgent itself. Every price comes from that company's own page, read November 16, 2026. The first row is the tool you are weighing. The last column says where each option beats us, and CommunityMentions is ours.
OptionWhat it doesWho postsPrice as published (November 16, 2026)ContractWhere it beats us
ReplyAgent (the one you're weighing)Reddit only: AI finds posts and drafts comments on the $79 plan; manual mode lets you find and write yourself; posting service for comments and postsIts aged accounts (100 to 10,000 karma), or your own account for free$4 a comment, $8 a post; AI features $79 a month ($699 a year); posting FAQ line shows $5 and $10Cancel anytime, by its page; posting is pay as you go with creditsPosting at $4 a comment, with no plan needed in manual mode
CrowdReplyAI visibility tracking, onsite content and a marketplace; offsite mentions bought with creditsIts marketplace, by its pageStarter $79 a month, Growth $239 (read November 19, 2026); no published per-comment price, credits $1 = 1 creditMonthly or yearly; yearly billing saves 20%Plans bundle AI visibility tracking and articles, and you see each placement's cost before you confirm
Mention.BrokerReddit mentions from its pool of verified Reddit usersIts postersFree plan covers 2 mentions; $34.99 a month for 10, a launch price against $49.99 list; $89.99 for 30 against $149.99Monthly plans, annual "coming soon"A fixed monthly plan from $34.99, and a free plan
ReplyGuyFinds conversations where someone asks for a tool like yours, drafts a reply and posts the ones you approveYour account on Reddit and Hacker News if you connect one, otherwise ReplyGuy'sPro $49 a month (10 keywords, up to 100 leads); Business $99; Enterprise $199; Agency $499Cancel, pause or change plan any time, by its FAQPosts for under $100 a month, on Reddit, Hacker News, X and YouTube
RedreachReddit lead finder with AI reply suggestions and competitor trackingYouStartup $19 a month (20 keywords, 100 reply suggestions, weekly leads); 3-day pass $12Monthly plan; pass is one timeLeads and reply drafts from $19 a month
RedShipDaily lead threads, competitor tracking, weekly AI-citation tracking, AI reply suggestionsYouFounder $29 a month (1 product, 10 keywords); Company $49 (3 products); 7-day pass $12Monthly, quarterly or yearly billingFrom $29 a month, with AI-citation tracking built in
Subreddit SignalsScores threads for buying intent, comment builder with voice profilesYouStarter $29 a month ($24 billed annually); Pro $59 ($49.17 annually); 14-day trial, card requiredCancel anytime, by its pageYour own voice on every comment
KWatchKeyword alerts with AI analysis of the contextYouFree (2 Reddit keywords); Essential $19 a month (20); Business $79 (100); Enterprise $199 (500)Plans prorated, stop anytime, by its FAQA free plan, and alerts from $19 a month
OutreachBloomSubreddit research and daily Reddit comments written for you, delivered ready to postYou, from your own branded account$2,400 a month for expert comments you post, no count stated; $4,900 a month for its AISEO planMonth to month, cancel anytimeYou approve and post every word from your own account
ReddiReachReddit and AI-search agency: posts and comments from a branded profile it managesReddiReach, from a branded profile$2,000 a month for 30 contributions; $5,000 a month adds articles3-month minimum, no refundsPosts as well as comments, at a published agency price
CommunityMentions (ours)Finds threads, writes comments in a voice you approve in Slack, posts on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X; we aim for 5 to 10 comments a day across all fivePeople with established accounts$1,000 a month after a $1 setup chargeMonth to monthNot applicable, it is ours

How much does ReplyAgent cost?

ReplyAgent has two prices that add together. Posting from its own accounts is $4 a comment and $8 a post, and its page gives 30 comments a month as $120 and 10 posts as $100. The AI features (post discovery, AI comments, daily monitoring, up to 3 products) need the Basic plan at $79 a month, or $699 a year. Its manual mode has no subscription: you find posts and write comments yourself, and you pay only if you want it to post. Its home page shows a 3-day trial of the $79 plan. One line in its billing FAQ reads differently from the cards: credits are deducted at "$5 when a comment is posted, $10 when a post is published", and refunded "if content is removed within 1 hour". Its cards say $4, $8 and a single 24 or 48 hour check. If you buy credits, check which price your dashboard shows.

Why teams look past ReplyAgent

  • The price has two parts. Thirty comments a month at $4 is $120, and the AI features that find the threads and write the drafts are another $79 a month, so about $199 a month at that volume. Manual mode drops the $79 and leaves the finding and writing to you.
  • Two prices on one page. The cards say $4 a comment and $8 a post; the billing FAQ says $5 and $10 are deducted, and refunds if removed within 1 hour. Its cards describe a single removal check at 24 hours for comments and 48 for posts.
  • A removal after the check is not refunded. Its page says content "still live at the check but removed later falls outside the refund window", and the refund is $2.80 of the $4, not the full price.
  • Reddit only. Its page, features and posting service are all about Reddit. A brand that also wants YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X comments needs another service.

What a year of each costs

A year of CommunityMentions at $1,000 a month plus the $1 setup charge comes to $12,001. The table counts the plan one brand would start on, at the price read November 16, 2026 (OutreachBloom's read November 18, 2026), billed monthly unless a row says otherwise. ReplyAgent is counted three ways, each at 30 comments a month at $4: manual mode with no plan, the $79 monthly plan, and the $699 yearly plan. CrowdReply is left out because it publishes no per-comment price. OutreachBloom and ReddiReach are agency prices: ReddiReach lists 30 monthly engagements and OutreachBloom states no count. Caption: prices from each company's own page, November 16, 2026; totals are our arithmetic.
OptionHow it's counted12 months
KWatch Essential$19 a month$228
Redreach Startup$19 a month$228
RedShip Founder$29 a month$348
Subreddit Signals Starter$29 a month$348
Mention.Broker Starter$34.99 a month for 10 mentions$419.88
ReplyGuy Pro$49 a month, billed monthly$588
ReplyAgent, manual mode30 comments a month at $4, no plan$1,440
ReplyAgent, yearly plan$699 a year plus 30 comments a month at $4$2,139
ReplyAgent, monthly plan$79 a month plus 30 comments a month at $4$2,388
CommunityMentions (ours)$1,000 a month plus $1$12,001
ReddiReach Reddit Growth$2,000 a month$24,000
OutreachBloom Reddit marketing$2,400 a month$28,800

What would three buyers pay?

A founder wanting 30 Reddit comments a month pays $120 with ReplyAgent in manual mode or $2,000 with ReddiReach; a team wanting threads found and drafted pays $79 for ReplyAgent's AI plan and posts itself; a brand wanting daily presence beyond Reddit has no ReplyAgent plan to buy. CommunityMentions is $1,000 a month for each. Each buyer is matched to the cheapest option on this page that does the job they describe. Caption: prices from each company's own page, November 16, 2026; the ReplyAgent figures are its own typical-usage numbers and our arithmetic.
BuyerReplyAgentCheapest agency at a published priceCheapest tool or pay-per-comment optionCommunityMentions (ours)
Solo founder, 30 Reddit comments a month on threads you choose$120 a month at $4 a comment, manual mode; $199 with the $79 AI planReddiReach, $2,000 a month for 30 contributions, 3-month minimumMention.Broker $34.99 for 10 mentions ($3.50 each); ReplyAgent $120 for 30 comments$1,000 a month, threads found for you
SaaS team of 5 that wants threads found and replies drafted, then posts from its own accounts$79 a month for the AI plan; you post from your own accounts for freeOutreachBloom, $2,400 a month for expert comments you post yourself, no count statedRedreach Startup $19 a month (100 reply suggestions); ReplyGuy Pro $49$1,000 a month, posted from established accounts, not yours
Brand that wants 1 comment a day on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and XReddit onlyNone on this page lists all five channelsReplyGuy Pro $49 a month posts on Reddit, Hacker News, X and YouTube$1,000 a month for all five channels, no contract

Who posts, and from whose account?

ReplyAgent posts from its own pool of aged accounts, 100 to 10,000 karma by its page, or you post from your own account for free in manual mode. That one question splits this list more than price does. Mention.Broker also posts from a network it runs, and CrowdReply sells placements from a marketplace, and Mention.Broker's page lists a median user karma of 5. ReplyGuy posts from your account on Reddit and Hacker News if you connect one. The tools and OutreachBloom leave posting to you. CommunityMentions has real people with established accounts post the comments, paid only when a comment sticks. We check every comment the afternoon it is posted, re-check it nightly for about a week, and the daily Slack report links the ones that passed. Some comments are removed over time, usually by a human moderator. If posting from your own account is a requirement, ReplyAgent's manual mode, ReplyGuy or OutreachBloom fit and we do not.

Which tools do AI answers name instead?

In our scan of November 2, 2026, we asked ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity eight buyer questions about Reddit marketing, three times each, so 96 answers in all. ReplyAgent was named in 9 of them (Claude 5, Perplexity 4): 5 on "What are the best alternatives to ReddiReach?" and 4 on "Is there a service that posts comments about my company on Reddit every day?". Two Claude answers gave its price as $3 a comment or post; its page now says $4 and $8. CommunityMentions was named in 17. The counts below use the same method for every name: an answer counts once when its text names the company.
CompanyAnswers naming it (of 96)
OutreachBloom29
ReddiReach18
CommunityMentions (ours)17
Redreach11
ReplyAgent9
RedShip8
Subreddit Signals6
KWatch6
ReplyGuy2
Mention.Broker2
CrowdReply2

Where ReplyAgent still wins

  • Price per comment. At $4 a comment, 30 comments a month is $120, against $1,000 a month for us, and its manual mode needs no plan. Only Mention.Broker's launch plans are lower per mention.
  • Pay as you go. Posting is bought with credits that its page says never expire, so you can order 5 comments one month and 50 the next, and its plan is cancel anytime.
  • A refund when a comment is removed by its check: $2.80 of the $4 back if moderators remove it at the 24-hour check, and a full refund if posting fails and never goes live.
  • You choose the threads. In manual mode you find the posts and write the comments, and the posting service puts them live, which suits a founder who already knows which threads matter.

Which one fits

Stay with ReplyAgent if you want to pick the threads yourself, pay per comment and keep volume small and Reddit-only. Move to Mention.Broker if you want the same pay-for-posting model on another network, or look at CrowdReply if you want placements from a credit marketplace. Use ReplyGuy, Redreach, RedShip, Subreddit Signals or KWatch if you want a tool for under $100 a month and will approve or write each reply. Pick OutreachBloom if you want every comment to go out from your own account at $2,400 a month. Choose CommunityMentions if you want threads found, comments written in a voice you approve in Slack, and posting done daily on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X for $1,000 a month, month to month, billed monthly only after you approve the setup in Slack. We aim for 5 to 10 comments a day across those channels combined. In the 30 days from October 7 to November 5, 2026, the median of 55 client brands got 49 verified placements across those channels, 9 of them on Reddit. The middle half ran from 2 to 123. That count includes brands that started or paused partway through the window. To see which subreddits AI answers cite for your product first, try the free subreddit finder. For the price line by line, see ReplyAgent pricing, and for a two-way view, CommunityMentions vs ReplyAgent.

How we compared

Every price comes from the company's own page, read November 16, 2026 with a browser-like request; only text a visitor sees counts, and a price found only in page code or comments is not treated as published. ReplyAgent here means replyagent.ai, the Reddit tool; replyagent.com is an unrelated CRM. Redreach renders its prices with JavaScript, so we read its Startup card in a browser; its higher plans are not counted here. CrowdReply was re-read on November 19, 2026, after it dropped its per-comment prices. Mention.Broker's prices are its launch prices, with the list price beside them. Claims a company makes about itself, such as account quality and refunds, are its own claims. The AI answer counts come from CommunityMentions' own scan of 96 answers on November 2, 2026. The 12-month figures are our arithmetic on the listed prices. If a company's page says something different now, its page wins.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

How much does ReplyAgent cost?

On November 16, 2026 its pricing page showed $4 a comment and $8 a post from its own accounts, and $79 a month ($699 a year) for the AI features. Manual mode has no subscription. One line in its billing FAQ says $5 and $10 are deducted per comment and post.

What is a cheaper alternative to ReplyAgent for Reddit?

For posting, only Mention.Broker is lower per item here, at $3.50 a mention on its $34.99 launch plan for 10. For finding threads, Redreach and KWatch start at $19 a month and RedShip at $29, and you write and post yourself. CommunityMentions, ours, is $1,000 a month after a $1 setup charge and posts for you on five channels.

Does ReplyAgent refund removed comments?

Its page says $2.80 of the $4 comes back if moderators remove a comment at its single 24-hour check, and a full refund if posting fails. Content removed after the check falls outside the refund window.

Is ReplyAgent only for Reddit?

Its pages describe Reddit only. CommunityMentions posts on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X; ReplyGuy covers Reddit, Hacker News, X and YouTube.

Is replyagent.com the same as ReplyAgent AI?

No. replyagent.ai is the Reddit marketing tool priced here. replyagent.com is an unrelated white-label CRM and automation site.

Which ReplyAgent alternative covers more than Reddit?

CommunityMentions posts on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X for $1,000 a month. ReplyGuy, from $49 a month, posts on Reddit, Hacker News, X and YouTube.

See the comments before you decide

Paste your site and get a free sample of the comments we'd post this week. No card.