Quick answer: who posts for you, and how often
- You want it done every day across Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X: CommunityMentions, $1,000 a month, month-to-month.
- You want software to find threads daily and a crew to post: ReplyAgent, $79 a month plus $4 a comment.
- You want exactly 30 Reddit comments a month for the least money: Mention.Broker Pro, $89.99 a month.
- You want an agency to run strategy and posting: ReddiReach, $2,000 a month for 30 contributions, 3 months minimum.
- You want comments plus tracking of AI answers: CrowdReply, $79 a month plus $10 a comment.
How we compared them
Compared November 12, 2026, from each vendor's own pricing page, read that day. Four criteria, in this order: someone else finds the threads and writes the comments, someone else posts them, its page says it keeps going every day without you placing each order, and its page says you can see or approve the voice before anything posts. We ranked by how many of those the vendor's own page states, and price breaks ties. Only CommunityMentions states all four; no other page we read states a voice preview. To compare like with like, the table prices 30 Reddit comments in a month, which is one a day. A service had to be on sale the day we read it. CommunityMentions is our service, and it is on this list.
What one comment a day for 30 days costs
Our arithmetic on each vendor's list prices, read November 12, 2026.
| # | Service | Who finds threads and writes | Who posts | 30 Reddit comments a month | Fine print |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CommunityMentions (ours) | We do; you approve the voice in Slack first | People with established accounts, every day of the week | $1,000 a month flat; not sold by count | Aims for 5 to 10 a day across five channels; the niche sets the real number; $1 setup charge; month-to-month |
| 2 | ReplyAgent | Its AI finds posts daily and drafts comments ($79 a month), or you do it free | Its aged accounts (100 to 10k karma), $4 a comment | $199 ($79 + 30 x $4) | $120 if you find and write yourself; ReplyAgent refunds 70% when a comment is found removed at its single 24-hour check |
| 3 | Mention.Broker | It hand-picks posts and hand-writes mentions from your keywords | Its network of real Reddit users (it says 30k+) | $89.99 (Pro plan, $3.00 each) | Launch price, listed at $149.99; Reddit only; a free plan with 2 mentions; satisfaction guarantee |
| 4 | ReddiReach | Its team, as a managed service | Its team, which writes every comment and post | $2,000 a month for 30 contributions (posts and comments) | 3-month minimum, so $6,000 to start; no refunds; no setup fee |
| 5 | CrowdReply | Social listening keywords find threads; comments are priced per task | Its network of platform-native accounts | $379 ($79 Starter + 30 x $10) | $15 for a comment with a link; plans include $600 a year in credits that may offset part of the per-comment cost (release schedule not stated); tracks AI answers too |
Why each one sits where it does
- 1. CommunityMentions is the only one here that finds, writes and posts every day on its own once you approve the voice, on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X, with a daily Slack report linking every comment that passed our check. Wrong for you if you need a set number of Reddit comments each month: in the 30 days to November 5, 2026 the median client brand got 9 on Reddit and 49 across all five channels. Mention.Broker sells a fixed 30.
- 2. ReplyAgent is the closest to a daily machine without the voice preview. Its AI looks for posts every day, and its crew posts each comment from aged accounts for $4. Its page does not say whether you see a comment before it posts, and it covers Reddit only.
- 3. Mention.Broker is the best price for a fixed Reddit count. Its people pick the threads and write the mentions from your keywords. It covers Reddit only, and its page does not say it posts on a daily schedule, so it ranks below ReplyAgent.
- 4. ReddiReach is a full agency, ranked above CrowdReply because it does the finding, writing and posting itself. 30 contributions a month is about one a day, but at $2,000 a month with a 3-month minimum it costs about 22 times Mention.Broker's price for the same count.
- 5. CrowdReply suits a team that also wants to watch AI answers, and it ranks last because you order each comment as a task. Comments cost $7 to $10 each by plan on top of the subscription, so 30 a month on Starter runs $379 before any credits.
Does anyone actually post every single day?
Only a recurring service does, and the count still moves with your niche. Per-comment sellers post when you order, so a daily rhythm is up to you. Our own numbers show the spread: across 55 client brands in the 30 days to November 5, 2026, the 25th percentile got 2 verified placements, the median 49 and the 75th percentile 123, out of 4,748 in all. The median brand's 9 on Reddit is under one a day on Reddit itself. That count includes brands that started or paused partway through. A small niche with few live threads gets fewer comments, from us or anyone, because a comment in a thread nobody reads does nothing.
Left off this list
- Vettted sells one-off packages of 10 Reddit mentions for $500, but all three Reddit packages showed Paused when we read them on November 12, 2026. See Vettted pricing.
What to ask before you pay anyone
Ask who presses post, whether you see the wording first, what happens when a moderator removes a comment, and whether you get a link to each one. For per-mention prices across eight sellers, see best places to buy Reddit mentions. For removal terms and checks, see buying Reddit mentions: prices and checks. For monthly prices across 16 services, see how much Reddit marketing costs. To judge the comments before you pay, see how to see sample comments first.
Sources
- Mention.Broker plans, ReplyAgent pricing, CrowdReply pricing, ReddiReach pricing, Vettted Reddit mentions, each read November 12, 2026.
- CommunityMentions delivery database: verified placements by client brand and channel, 30 days October 7 to November 5, 2026, 55 brands, read November 6, 2026.
- CommunityMentions price and terms: Stripe price for the monthly service ($1,000) and the $1 setup payment link, read October 30, 2026.