Who wrote this and how we checked
Quick picks: what are you doing?
- A scoped agency program with a named strategist and AI-citation reporting, and $5,000 a month or more to spend: Soar.
- A branded subreddit built and run for you: Soar lists it as a service.
- A published price, daily proof per comment and no minimum term: CommunityMentions at $1,000 a month.
- Posting on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X together: CommunityMentions.
- Unsure about either: read the CommunityMentions free sample, then ask Soar for a proposal and its term in writing.
Soar vs CommunityMentions at a glance
| Soar (read Nov 6, 2026) | CommunityMentions | |
|---|---|---|
| Published price | None. The agency page offers "Request a Proposal"; soar.sh/pricing returned 404 | $1,000/mo after a $1 setup charge |
| Price in its blog | Retainer tiers of $5K, $10K and $15K a month (post updated May 9, 2026) | Same $1,000 for every client |
| Minimum term | Not stated on the agency page; its blog calls $5K engagements "90-day pilots" | None, month-to-month |
| Who posts | Agency-managed accounts, "aged, hand-picked for relevant subreddit history, and manually warmed for weeks" | People with established accounts post comments AI drafts in the voice you approve in Slack |
| Process | Four steps: Map (15 to 30 subreddits), Seed, Compound, Measure | Daily comments across five channels |
| Volume | $5K tier: one or two subreddits, 20 to 30 hours of mostly junior time; $15K tier: 8 to 15 subreddits, 60 to 80 hours | We aim for 5 to 10 comments a day across Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X combined; the median of 55 client brands got 49 verified placements in the 30 days to Nov 5, 2026, 9 on Reddit |
| Reporting | Monthly: ranked queries, AI citations captured, sentiment delta, attributed traffic, converted users | Daily Slack report with a link to each live comment |
| Removed comments | No guarantee stated; pre-submission checks cover subreddit rules, flair, recent removals and mod history | Checked the afternoon it is posted and nightly for about a week; a removed comment shows as removed |
| Channels | Reddit, Quora, Discord, plus Reddit ads to amplify winning threads | Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X; no Reddit ads |
| Upvotes and aged accounts | Sold through its self-serve brand, Signals | Not sold |
| Track record it states | "Up since 2017", 280+ campaigns, 4,205+ threads | 58,191 Reddit comments verified across 8,792 subreddits since November 2025 |
| How you start | Proposal or call | Free sample of the comments we would post, no card |
| Where they publish proof | Case studies with figures on its site | Daily report per client; aggregate numbers on /company |
How much does Soar cost per month?
Who posts the comments, and from which accounts?
What does the reporting cover?
What happens when a comment is removed?
How fast does it start?
What do AI answers say about Soar and CommunityMentions?
Where Soar still wins
- Reporting on AI citations. Its monthly report covers ranked queries and AI citations captured. We do not track AI answers for clients.
- Reddit ads on top. It uses Reddit ads to amplify winning threads. We place organic comments only.
- A custom program. A proposal can be scoped to your subreddits and goals, where we sell one plan. Its $10K and $15K tiers add senior strategist time, biweekly reviews and crisis response.
- Quora and Discord. We do not post there.
- Subreddit building and reputation work. Its site lists building and running a branded subreddit, and pushing a negative thread off Google's first page. We place comments and do neither.
- Longer public track record. Soar says it has been up since 2017 and shows case studies with figures. We started in November 2025.
Which one fits a B2B team
Sources, read November 6, 2026
- Soar Reddit marketing agency page: proposal-only pricing, four-step process, accounts, reporting metrics, channels
- Soar home page: AI Visibility at $950 a month plus a $500 setup, services, "up since 2017", 280+ campaigns, 4,205+ threads
- Soar pricing URL: returned 404 again
- Soar blog, Reddit agency pricing tiers in 2026: $5K, $10K and $15K tiers, 90-day pilot framing, updated May 9, 2026
- Strandline Research comparison of 11 done-for-you Reddit marketing services (same owner as CommunityMentions)
- CommunityMentions numbers: our delivery database, 55 client brands, 30 days from October 7 to November 5, 2026; company facts