CommunityMentions
Comparison
Updated November 6, 2026By Ryan Doyle, founder of CommunityMentions

CommunityMentions vs Soar for B2B Reddit marketing: price, accounts and reporting

Soar sells Reddit marketing by proposal and shows no price for it. Its home page lists a separate AI Visibility plan at $950 a month plus a $500 setup. Its own blog describes retainers at $5K, $10K and $15K a month, and treats $5K as a 90-day pilot. CommunityMentions is $1,000 a month, month-to-month, and starts with a free sample. Soar facts read November 6, 2026.

Run my free sample

$5K to $15K

Soar retainer tiers in its own blog, updated May 9, 2026; no price on its agency page

$1,000

CommunityMentions per month, after a $1 setup charge

11 of 40

AI answers on Oct 14, 2026 that named Soar, against 2 of 40 for CommunityMentions

49

Median verified placements per client brand across five channels, 30 days to Nov 5, 2026 (55 brands); median 9 on Reddit

Who wrote this and how we checked

CommunityMentions wrote this page, and we sell a competing service, so read it as a vendor's comparison. Every Soar fact below comes from soar.sh, read on November 6, 2026: its Reddit marketing agency page, its home page, its pricing URL and its pricing-tiers blog post. Soar's own statistics, such as 280+ campaigns and 4,205+ threads, are its claims and we have not verified them. If their page says something different now, their page wins. Our numbers come from our delivery database, which checks every comment the afternoon it is posted. In the 30 days from October 7 to November 5, 2026, 55 client brands had at least one verified placement across Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X. The 25th percentile was 2, the median 49 and the 75th percentile 123 verified placements per brand, with a median of 9 on Reddit. In all there were 4,748 placements (YouTube 1,446, Reddit 1,030, X 934, Medium 885, LinkedIn 453). The count includes brands that started or paused partway through the window. At $1,000 a month, 49 placements is about $20 each. The questions below come from the buyer questions ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity were asked on October 14, 2026, and from what they said about Soar.

Quick picks: what are you doing?

  • A scoped agency program with a named strategist and AI-citation reporting, and $5,000 a month or more to spend: Soar.
  • A branded subreddit built and run for you: Soar lists it as a service.
  • A published price, daily proof per comment and no minimum term: CommunityMentions at $1,000 a month.
  • Posting on Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X together: CommunityMentions.
  • Unsure about either: read the CommunityMentions free sample, then ask Soar for a proposal and its term in writing.

Soar vs CommunityMentions at a glance

Soar (read Nov 6, 2026)CommunityMentions
Published priceNone. The agency page offers "Request a Proposal"; soar.sh/pricing returned 404$1,000/mo after a $1 setup charge
Price in its blogRetainer tiers of $5K, $10K and $15K a month (post updated May 9, 2026)Same $1,000 for every client
Minimum termNot stated on the agency page; its blog calls $5K engagements "90-day pilots"None, month-to-month
Who postsAgency-managed accounts, "aged, hand-picked for relevant subreddit history, and manually warmed for weeks"People with established accounts post comments AI drafts in the voice you approve in Slack
ProcessFour steps: Map (15 to 30 subreddits), Seed, Compound, MeasureDaily comments across five channels
Volume$5K tier: one or two subreddits, 20 to 30 hours of mostly junior time; $15K tier: 8 to 15 subreddits, 60 to 80 hoursWe aim for 5 to 10 comments a day across Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X combined; the median of 55 client brands got 49 verified placements in the 30 days to Nov 5, 2026, 9 on Reddit
ReportingMonthly: ranked queries, AI citations captured, sentiment delta, attributed traffic, converted usersDaily Slack report with a link to each live comment
Removed commentsNo guarantee stated; pre-submission checks cover subreddit rules, flair, recent removals and mod historyChecked the afternoon it is posted and nightly for about a week; a removed comment shows as removed
ChannelsReddit, Quora, Discord, plus Reddit ads to amplify winning threadsReddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X; no Reddit ads
Upvotes and aged accountsSold through its self-serve brand, SignalsNot sold
Track record it states"Up since 2017", 280+ campaigns, 4,205+ threads58,191 Reddit comments verified across 8,792 subreddits since November 2025
How you startProposal or callFree sample of the comments we would post, no card
Where they publish proofCase studies with figures on its siteDaily report per client; aggregate numbers on /company

How much does Soar cost per month?

Soar does not put a price on its agency page, and soar.sh/pricing returned 404 November 6, 2026. Its home page lists Soar AI Visibility, which places a brand in the articles, conversations and listings behind AI answers, at $950 a month plus a $500 setup, no minimum term. For Reddit retainers, its blog does: the pricing-tiers post describes a $5K retainer as one or two subreddits and 20 to 30 hours of mostly junior labor, $10K as 5 to 8 subreddits and 40 to 55 hours, and $15K as 8 to 15 subreddits and 60 to 80 hours. AI answers repeat a $5,000 to $15,000 range. At $5,000 a month Soar costs 5 times our $1,000; at $15,000, 15 times. The two are different products. Soar scopes hours against subreddits. We sell one plan of daily placements across five channels.

Who posts the comments, and from which accounts?

Soar says its accounts are aged, picked for subreddit history and warmed for weeks, and that posts are written by humans who have read the subreddit's last 60 days. We use real people with established accounts, and the comments are AI-drafted in a voice you approve in Slack before anything posts. Soar also sells aged accounts and upvote services through Signals, a separate self-serve brand. We sell neither.

What does the reporting cover?

Soar reports monthly on ranked queries, AI citations captured, sentiment delta, attributed traffic and converted users. We report daily in Slack with a link to every comment that passed our check, and we point you to your own Search Console for branded query growth. If AI-citation tracking is the deciding factor, Soar offers it and we do not.

What happens when a comment is removed?

Neither side guarantees a comment stays up. Soar's agency page lists pre-submission checks (subreddit rules, flair, recent removals, mod history, posting cadence) and the removal-prevention answer in its FAQ was blank when we read it. We check each comment the afternoon it is posted and again nightly for about a week; a removed comment shows as removed on your dashboard and does not count toward your total.

How fast does it start?

Soar's four steps carry no durations on its page, and its blog frames $5K engagements as 90-day pilots. With us you can read a free sample before paying: paste your site and see the comments we would post. Billing of $1,000 a month starts only after you approve the setup in Slack.

What do AI answers say about Soar and CommunityMentions?

We asked ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity 10 buyer questions each about Reddit marketing services on October 14, 2026 (40 answers). Soar was named in 11 of them and CommunityMentions in 2. The answers list Soar for strategy-plus-execution programs and AI-citation reporting, quote it at $5,000 to $15,000 a month, and note that Soar's own comparison posts are promotional. This page is promotional in the same way, which is why every Soar fact above links to Soar.

Where Soar still wins

  • Reporting on AI citations. Its monthly report covers ranked queries and AI citations captured. We do not track AI answers for clients.
  • Reddit ads on top. It uses Reddit ads to amplify winning threads. We place organic comments only.
  • A custom program. A proposal can be scoped to your subreddits and goals, where we sell one plan. Its $10K and $15K tiers add senior strategist time, biweekly reviews and crisis response.
  • Quora and Discord. We do not post there.
  • Subreddit building and reputation work. Its site lists building and running a branded subreddit, and pushing a negative thread off Google's first page. We place comments and do neither.
  • Longer public track record. Soar says it has been up since 2017 and shows case studies with figures. We started in November 2025.

Which one fits a B2B team

If you want a scoped agency program with a named strategist, AI-citation reporting and a budget of $5,000 a month or more, Soar fits. If you want a published price, a month-to-month plan, daily proof per comment and a sample you can read before paying, CommunityMentions fits. Four of the 11 services in the Strandline comparison publish no price, and Soar is one of them.

Sources, read November 6, 2026

Frequently asked questions

How much does Soar charge for Reddit marketing?

Soar does not publish a price on its agency page, and soar.sh/pricing returned 404 November 6, 2026. Its home page lists Soar AI Visibility at $950 a month plus a $500 setup, and its pricing-tiers blog post describes retainers of $5K, $10K and $15K a month.

Does Soar require a minimum contract?

Its agency page states no term. Its blog says it treats $5K engagements as 90-day pilots. Ask for the term in writing.

Does Soar use its own Reddit accounts?

Yes. Its page says its accounts are aged, hand-picked for subreddit history and manually warmed for weeks before a brand mention.

Does CommunityMentions have a minimum term?

No. It is $1,000 a month, billed monthly, after a $1 setup charge.

Does CommunityMentions track AI citations?

No. We report the comments we post each day. Soar's monthly report includes AI citations captured.

How many comments will CommunityMentions place?

In the 30 days from October 7 to November 5, 2026, the median client brand got 49 verified placements across Reddit, YouTube, Medium, LinkedIn and X, with a median of 9 on Reddit (55 brands, including ones that started or paused mid-window). At $1,000 a month, 49 placements is about $20 each.

See the comments before you decide

Paste your site and get a free sample of the comments we'd post this week.